Carolina Herrera Good Girl vs Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium
Carolina Herrera
Good Girl
EDP · 2016
Louise Turner
Yves Saint Laurent
Black Opium
EDP · 2014
Nathalie Lorson, Marie Salamagne, Olivier Cresp & Honorine Blanc
What they share
3 materials appear in both.
Only in Carolina Herrera Good Girl
Only in Yves Saint Laurent Black Opium
Main accords
Both accord profiles, side by side. What separates them most comes first; a missing bar means the perfume does not carry that accord.
Gender
Good Girl
Woman
Woman
Man
Black Opium
Woman
Woman
Man
A guide to how it's perceived, not a rule — anyone can wear any perfume.
Good Girl
Longevity
9/10
Sillage
8/10
Season
Occasion
Black Opium
Longevity
8/10
Sillage
7/10
Season
Occasion
Good Girl
Almond and coffee against tuberose: the contrast of light and shadow, claimed right down to the bottle. Dense and very persistent.
Black Opium
Black coffee and vanilla over a patchouli base. Addictive, nocturnal, the signature of a generation.